Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Dog Training

How to Get a Dog Interested in Puzzle Toys: 7 Effective Tips & Tricks

Lindsey Lawson
By Lindsey Lawson · Reviewed & fact-checked by Dr. Paola CuevasVet Approved
Dr. Paola Cuevas
Reviewed & Fact-Checked byDr. Paola CuevasVeterinarian
Dr. Paola Cuevas is our Senior In-House Veterinarian at Dogster and Pangolia. She has over 19 years of experience working with an array of species and loves sharing her knowledge and experience with our readers and aims to provide assistance with any issue presented by your non-human family members. She received her degree from the University of Guadalajara, Mexico.View authorThe information is current and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research. Learn more
Updated on June 17, 2026
Share
How to Get a Dog Interested in Puzzle Toys: 7 Effective Tips & Tricks

One way humans like to keep their brains sharp and prevent boredom is by diving into various types of puzzles. This can go for your dog, too. There are plenty of interactive puzzle toys designed specifically for dogs that help feed their curiosity and provide them with some much-needed mental stimulation.

The benefits of puzzle toys are incredible, but how do you get your dog interested in puzzle toys in the first place? We have some tips and tricks below to help you pique your dog’s interest and get them started with these handy toys.

divider single dog paw oct 2024

The 7 Tips and Tricks to Get a Dog Interested in Puzzle Toys

1. Keep it Simple

When you are first introducing your dog to puzzle toys, make sure you keep things as simple as possible. Some puzzle toys will be more challenging than others, so if you have one that has different difficulty levels, be sure to start on the easiest level and work your way up.

Certain dogs may be up for the challenge right from the get-go, but others may not be willing to take on an unfamiliar challenge that doesn’t provide them with an immediate reward. If the toy contains treats, make sure they can get to them easily at first.

Image Credit: Alexei_tm, Shutterstock

2. Show Your Dog How It Works

If your dog is showing no interest in the challenge of a particular toy, show them how it is supposed to work. Get their attention and once they are fixated on you, show them how it works by doing it yourself and make sure they see the reward at the end of the puzzle.


3. Test Out Different Puzzle Toys

There is a wide variety of puzzle toys available, so you may have to try out a few to see which style suits your dog’s interest. Consider your dog’s toy preferences when deciding on which puzzle toy to try out. Does your dog like playing with balls? If so, get a puzzle toy that has a ball included.

A lot of puzzle toys use treat motivation to keep them entertained. These toys will vary in difficulty and ultimately lead your dog to get a treat or food item (such as peanut butter) as a reward.

Image Credit: Lenti Hill, Shutterstock

4. Keep the Toy Put Away When Not in Use

To add more value to a new puzzle toy, keep it put away until playtime. When your dog has constant access to a certain toy, it can quickly lose its appeal because it’s always available. You will add an element of excitement to playtime when you only pull out the toy during certain, happy occasions.


5. Show Excitement and Give Praise

Your dog is highly affected by your energy and emotions, and you can use this to help get them excited about their new puzzle toy. Each time you take out the toy, use lots of excitement and enthusiasm so they have a positive association with the toy and can share in your excitement.

Once your dog starts actively engaging in play with the puzzle toy, use lots of praise to reinforce to them that this is what you want them to do.

Image Credit: ChickenStock Images, Shutterstock

6. Keep Play Sessions Short

Dogs are intelligent creatures, and they can become bored very easily, even when it comes to playing. A lot of dog trainers recommend short training sessions that only last 15 or less to keep their focus and prevent them from becoming distracted.

If you want your dog to have more interest in their new puzzle toy, bring it out when you’re ready for playtime and keep that time short and limited to prevent boredom and distractions.


7. Use Their Favorite Treats

Most puzzle toys use treats as a motivation to get them to solve the puzzle. If your dog is lacking interest in a particular toy, try putting their favorite treat in there to see if you can get a response.

If your dog is not treat-motivated, you may have to go a different avenue and try a puzzle that isn’t geared toward treats. There are plenty of options available and depending on your dog’s interest, you are sure to find something that works.

Image Credit: Reddogs, Shutterstock
divider dog paws 3 oct 2024

Benefits of Using Puzzle Toys

There are plenty of benefits that puzzle toys offer to both dogs and their owners. Here’s a quick look at some of the reasons you should offer puzzle toys to your dog.

Helps Alleviate Boredom

Whether you are busy doing things around the house, or you must leave your dog at home for a while you are out and about, puzzle toys can be a highly effective way to alleviate their boredom and keep them occupied while you aren’t presently engaging with them.

These toys are designed to give them a challenge, which stimulates them both physically and mentally. The more challenging the toy, the longer your dog will be occupied. Boredom can lead to many unwanted behaviors, so it’s always good to have entertainment handy.

Provides Exercise and Mental Stimulation

Dogs should be getting at least 30 minutes or more of exercise each day, which can be difficult to fit in if you have a busier schedule. Puzzle toys are one way to keep your dog physically -and mentally stimulated since they bring about new ways of being active.

Acts as a Distraction for Separation Anxiety

Numerous dogs suffer from moderate to severe separation anxiety when they are apart from their human family. Puzzle toys can help distract these dogs from feeling anxious by keeping them preoccupied as they try and solve their puzzle and get their treat or reward. An experienced veterinarian can give you some great advice on other possible ways to distract your dog.

Great for Fast Eaters and Those with Sensitive Stomachs

Some puzzle toys are designed specifically for dinner time. Puzzle feeders are a great way to slow down eating and help aid in digestion. These crafty, maze-like bowls are not just made to keep your dog stimulated, but they are great for that too.  The challenging setup keeps them from gulping down mouthfuls of food, which can help prevent regurgitation and bloat.

Prevents Destructive Behaviors

Last but not least, interactive puzzle toys can significantly help reduce destructive behaviors that result in damage and ruin to various household items. Destructive behavior can be a result of fear, boredom, or anxiety and puzzle toys can help alleviate these issues by keeping them occupied, distracted, and entertained.

Image Credit: Ryan Brix, Shutterstock
divider dog faces oct 2024

Summary

If your dog doesn’t take naturally to puzzle toys at first, there are plenty of ideas you can implement to help get them into it. Thankfully, there is no shortage of variety so even if your dog doesn’t like a certain style, you have plenty more you can try out for size. Puzzle toys are not only great for their mental health but their physical health, too.

See also:

Sources

Featured Image Credit: Lenti Hill, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

Lindsey Lawson
Authored by

Lindsey Lawson

OneMind Dogs Online Training Review 2026: Lorelei Goes Back To School

OneMind Dogs Online Training Review 2026: Lorelei Goes Back To School

We humans love to have our hobbies, especially athletic ones. Did you know that our four-legged best friends enjoy hobbies just as much? If anything, they cons…

Lisa Lee
By Lisa Lee · 1 week ago
How to Train a Husky: 7 Vet Approved Tips & Tricks

How to Train a Husky: 7 Vet Approved Tips & Tricks

The Siberian Husky’s joyous energy and unconditional friendliness make them one of the most delightful dogs to own, but any pet parent can tell you how challen…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove · 1 week ago
How to Train a Rottweiler: 7 Vet-Approved Tips & Tricks

How to Train a Rottweiler: 7 Vet-Approved Tips & Tricks

Training a Rottweiler is relatively straightforward due to the breed’s commitment to family and eagerness to please, but that doesn’t mean you have room to sla…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove · 1 week ago
Why Are Police Dogs Called K9? History & Facts

Why Are Police Dogs Called K9? History & Facts

The history of using canines for police and military work goes back to the Romans using Neapolitan Mastiffs on the battlefield as “dogs of war.” However, polic…

Chris Dinesen Rogers
By Chris Dinesen Rogers · 1 week ago
Dogster’s Weekly Photo Contest Winners: The Head Tilt (June 22, 2026)
June 25, 2026

Every week our team gets the privilege of sorting through our readers photos to choose what dogs will win this weeks contest! See all the winners here

Radim Chudej
By Radim Chudej
Why Environmental Awareness Matters for Dog Wellness
June 25, 2026

When pet parents think about supporting their dog's health, nutrition, exercise, and regular veterinary care often come to mind first. Increasingly, however, r…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove
Why I Created Chi Dog: Whole Food Nutrition That Supports Dogs From the Inside Out
June 16, 2026

After more than 15 years practicing as an integrative veterinarian, I saw the same pattern over and over again. Dogs were struggling with skin allergies, chron…

Dr. Susan Bohrer DVM, CVA
By Dr. Susan Bohrer DVM, CVA
The Most Common Shih Tzu Health Problems to Watch Out For, According to Vets
June 25, 2026

Shih Tzus are popular and sweet little dogs. They are affectionate, spirited, surprisingly resilient for their size, and with an expected lifespan ranging from…

Dan Seymour
By Dan Seymour

Love Dogs? So Do We! Join the Dogster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.

You may opt-out at any time. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

The Dogster app on a phone